Whodunnit Wednesday: Night Film by Marisha Pessl

It’s Whodunnit Wednesday, the midweek moment where we dive into the dark, the twisty, and the absolutely unputdownable. And this week’s pick? One that still haunts me in the best way:

🎬 Night Film by Marisha Pessl
Genre: Psychological thriller / noir mystery with a meta twist
Vibe: Think David Fincher meets Donna Tartt, then throws you into a cursed film archive


🕯️ The Premise:

When Ashley Cordova, the brilliant and troubled daughter of a legendary (and reclusive) horror filmmaker, is found dead in an apparent suicide, investigative journalist Scott McGrath isn’t buying it. His obsession with her father—cult icon Stanislas Cordova—once ruined his career, but now Ashley’s death might be the key to the story he could never quite crack.

As Scott plunges into a shadowy world of secret screenings, eerie fan forums, underground operatives, and psychological unraveling, the question becomes not just what happened to Ashley, but how deep does the rabbit hole go?


🌀 What Makes This One So Unsettling:

  • Multimedia elements: Newspaper clippings, web forums, photos—it all pulls you into the story like you’re the investigator.
  • Cordova’s films: Invented movies so disturbingly vivid you’ll wish (and maybe regret) that they were real.
  • Unreliable everything: Narrators, clues, reality itself. This book gaslights you—in the most artful way.

🧠 The Big Question:

Did Ashley Cordova really take her own life? Or was it something… stranger? Darker? A carefully constructed legend, or a truth too twisted to accept?


🔍 Your Turn, Detectives:

What do you think really happened in Night Film?
If you’ve read it:
🗨️ Were you convinced by the ending? Or do you believe there’s more lurking beneath the surface?

If you haven’t:
🕯️ Are you brave enough to follow Cordova’s trail?

Drop your theories in the comments—and if you’re feeling bold, tell me your favorite fictional filmmaker or creepiest movie-related book you’ve read.

Until next Wednesday, keep your flashlights close and your sanity closer. 🔦📖


Discover more from literary gluttony

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a comment