Because not every great book is trending on BookTok
Not every good book comes with hype. Some slip quietly onto shelves, get read once or twice, and then disappear into the void of “why does no one talk about this?” These are the books that don’t show up in viral recommendation videos, don’t get endless special editions, and somehow never become part of the collective reading conversation—despite being genuinely good.
This isn’t a list of hidden gems no one’s ever heard of. These books exist. They’ve been published, reviewed, and loved by someone. They’re just rarely recommended loudly or often enough.
If you’re tired of seeing the same handful of titles recycled in every list, these are worth your attention.
The Night Circus Is Not the Only Magical Book
📖 The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker
This book is quiet, patient, and deeply atmospheric. Set in turn-of-the-century New York, it follows two supernatural beings trying to understand humanity—and each other—in a world that isn’t built for them.
Why it’s underrated: it doesn’t rush, it doesn’t spoon-feed, and it doesn’t fit neatly into a trend. But the payoff is worth it if you enjoy slow-burn storytelling and rich historical detail.
Read this if you like: lush writing, character-driven fantasy, and stories that feel like they’re unfolding rather than performing.
A Romance That Doesn’t Rely on Big Drama
📖 Attachments by Rainbow Rowell
Often overshadowed by Rowell’s more well-known titles, Attachments is an unexpectedly tender, low-stakes romance that unfolds almost entirely through emails.
Why it’s underrated: there’s no dramatic love triangle, no explosive conflict, no grand gestures. It’s subtle, awkward, and deeply human—which makes it easy to overlook in a genre that often rewards spectacle.
Read this if you like: quiet yearning, emotional restraint, and romances that feel earned rather than engineered.
A Thriller That’s More Psychological Than Shocking
📖 The Last House on Needless Street by Catriona Ward
This one is often marketed as a twisty horror novel, but it’s far more layered than that. It’s unsettling without being gratuitous, and emotionally complex in ways that linger long after you finish.
Why it’s underrated: it’s difficult to categorize, and books that defy easy labels often get missed.
Read this if you like: unreliable narrators, slow reveals, and stories that challenge your assumptions rather than relying on jump scares.
Historical Fiction That Feels Intimate, Not Sweeping
📖 The Pull of the Stars by Emma Donoghue
Set during the 1918 flu pandemic, this novel unfolds almost entirely in a single maternity ward over three days. It’s claustrophobic, tender, and quietly devastating.
Why it’s underrated: it doesn’t romanticize history or turn suffering into spectacle. It’s small in scope but heavy in impact.
Read this if you like: emotionally immersive historical fiction and stories centered on overlooked moments rather than major events.
For Readers Who Love Flawed Women
📖 Supper Club by Lara Williams
This is a messy, sharp, sometimes uncomfortable book about female friendship, food, desire, and ambition. It won’t be for everyone—but that’s exactly why it deserves more discussion.
Why it’s underrated: it refuses to make its protagonist likable in conventional ways, and it doesn’t soften its edges to be more palatable.
Read this if you like: morally gray characters, feminist rage simmering under the surface, and books that aren’t interested in being “nice.”
Why These Books Matter
Underrated doesn’t mean obscure—it often means unmarketable. These books don’t fit trends cleanly, don’t promise instant gratification, and don’t always lend themselves to quick summaries. But they reward readers who are willing to slow down, sit with discomfort, or embrace subtlety.
If you’ve been in a reading rut, picking up something slightly off the recommendation beaten path can be exactly what shakes things loose.
If you’ve read any of these, I’d love to know which ones worked for you—or which underrated reads you wish more people talked about. Some of the best book conversations happen far away from the algorithm.
literary gluttony 
Leave a comment